You are better at comparing than at scoring
Ask someone to rate nine priorities out of ten and you get a wall of sevens and eights. Ask them which of two matters more and the answer arrives almost instantly. This is the oldest finding in psychometrics: Thurstone's law of comparative judgment showed that relative judgments between two items are far more consistent than absolute ratings on a scale. The Forced Choice never asks you to score anything. It only ever asks: this one, or that one?